Where Do Leaders Take Their Unfinished Thinking?

In this article, mentor Paula Reynolds explains how executive mentoring works, why even the most experienced CEOs and board chairs benefit from a confidential sounding board, how an engagement begins and how it can be tailored to different leadership situations.

Board Effectiveness & Governance, Executive Performance, Global Mentors Group News, Leadership & Mentoring, Organisational Culture

With decades of leadership experience across senior executive and board roles, Paula Reynolds has seen first-hand what it takes to lead through complexity and change. Now, as a mentor to senior executives, she reflects on the lessons her experience has taught her and why perspective and having the space to think matters when navigating the most important decisions of a leadership career.


Every significant decision I made as Chair started life as a half-formed idea, and most of them were not ready to be shared.

That is the part of leadership that rarely gets discussed. Boards see the finished proposal. Executive teams see the plan. What almost nobody sees is the gestational phase – the stretch of weeks when a leader is privately testing an instinct, wondering whether a concern is real, or weighing a move that could reshape the organisation or their own career.

It is also the phase where judgement is formed. Increasingly, judgement is the job.

Senior leaders now carry an extraordinary load: technology moving faster than strategy cycles, geopolitical uncertainty, shifting trade rules, heavier regulation. Defining risk appetite and risk tolerance used to feel like a governance exercise. Now it sits squarely with the individual at the top. Technique, experience, and data help, but ultimately, someone still must make the call.

So where does a leader take that unfinished thinking?

The obvious answers are the Chair, fellow directors and trusted colleagues. They are valuable, and I too relied on them throughout my career. But each has a stake in the outcome. Sharing an idea too early with the people who will judge it changes the idea itself, and sometimes it changes how the leader is perceived. Even the most proven executives hold back for exactly that reason.

What is often missing is a room with no agenda. A place where an executive can try out an idea before it’s fully formed, sharpen their judgement, reframe a problem and find out what actually matters most, with someone who has sat in a similar chair and has nothing to gain from the answer.

That is why I mentor.

Experience Matters. Perspective Even More

A mentor brings experience, but mentoring is not about handing that experience over as a set of instructions.

The circumstances of one leader are never the same as those of another. What worked for me, or for another executive I have known, may not be the right answer for the person sitting across from me.

The value of experience is that it provides a basis to listen, understand, advise, and encourage. It allows a mentor to draw on situations they have faced themselves, share a perspective, ask questions, and help an executive consider different approaches.

The executive remains responsible for the decision.

That is why the best mentoring conversations are often less about giving advice and more about listening, questioning, challenging assumptions, and creating space for an executive to think.

And when you create that space, the conversation often goes beyond the immediate business problem. In my experience, some of the most valuable conversations are about the transitions that define a career: stepping into the C-suite, finding your comfort zone in a new role, competing in a succession process, stepping away from a long-held position, or leaving something comfortable for something that is a step into the unknown.

They can be about success that needs a champion and disappointment that needs to be absorbed quietly. They can also be about the parts of leadership that do not appear in a board paper: managing relationships, balancing career and family, dealing with a difficult board dynamic, or working out how to be strong while remaining authentic.

Trust changes the conversation

For that to happen, there has to be trust. A senior leader needs to know that they can speak openly, including when their thinking is unfinished or uncomfortable, without having to manage the consequences of what they say.

Absolute confidentiality is essential to the relationship. It creates a safe place for an executive to try out ideas and consider different approaches and perspectives. The mentor must be able to listen without an agenda and challenge without judgement. There needs to be honesty, mutual respect and a genuine willingness to understand what is really going on.

That creates something increasingly rare for senior leaders: protected time to think.

Helping leaders discover what they already know

There is a line often attributed to Galileo: “You cannot teach a man anything. You can only help him discover it within himself.”

That idea has stayed with me because it captures what I believe good mentoring should do.

A mentor does not hand over answers. The insight is often already there. It may simply be obscured by the pace of leadership, the weight of responsibility or the noise surrounding a difficult decision.

The right conversation can create enough space to find it. Sometimes that leads to a decision. Sometimes it leads to a different question. Sometimes it simply gives a leader the confidence to trust their own judgement.

No executive, regardless of experience and talent, can navigate the leadership journey alone. The best leaders understand this. They simply need the right person, and the right space, to think.

Related Insights

Your pathway to exceptional leadership

It starts with a conversation – and leads to lasting impact

Connect with us

The Original Mentor

Mentoring has its roots in one of the oldest leadership stories. In Homer’s Odyssey, Mentor was entrusted with guiding the young Telemachus while Odysseus was away — not by directing him, but by offering judgement, perspective and wisdom born of experience. This enduring idea of counsel, grounded in trust rather than instruction, remains the essence of mentoring today.

That same tradition sits at the heart of Global Mentors Group today. 

We exist to provide leaders with access to seasoned peers who have walked the path before them, offering the clarity, judgement and discretion required to lead at the highest level.

Global Mentors Group
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.